message board home
Next
6/24/2019 2:08:16 PM
 
Reply
or ReplyNewSubject
Section 8: Handguns Subject: S & W.41 Magnum Msg# 1049858
|
||||||
|
Beautiful gun. If ANYBODY thinks a lead bullet of about 210 grains in 41 caliber traveling at 900 to 1000 FPS won't stop an argument they know NOTHING about terminal ballistics. The 41 Magnum could have been the greatest duty revolver of all times if promoted as originally conceived!
Waiting to hear back from grandson re the ammo they are using and the bullet weight, for some reason I keep thinking it's in the low to mid 70's? |
||||||
|
|
||||||
|
For reference, the above message is a reply to a message where: This was actually the large N-frame designed for the .41 Magnum in 1964 when S&W tried to come out with the ideal police cartridge and revolver. Unfortunately instead of a heavy lead bullet at 900 to 1000fps, they came out with a lead bullet several hundred fps faster that recoiled heavily, was too difficult to shoot, and to add insult to injury, leaded barrels horribly. And this was the "downloaded" LSWC version of the JSP they came out with for the adjustable-sighted version of the revolver, the Model 57. The lack of acceptance of the .41 Magnum by the police and even by the general public for its original purpose, self-defense, comes down entirely to Smith & Wesson dropping the ball badly. They had been advised by Bill Jordan and Skeeter Skelton if memory serves as to what was desired, a big bore midway between the .38 Special and .44 Special in size and throwing a heavy bullet, and they muffed it. Today the .41 Magnum is known as a hunting round and is a niche cartridge, loved by a few only. And while we no longer have the same respect for heavy bullets moving at moderate velocities for self-defense, if the .41 Magnum had come out according to desires, it would have been a winner. The Model 58 pictured is quite the collectible, as it is the last N-frame Military & Police model revolver Smith & Wesson ever built. I'd enjoy having one in my safe. Here's a better photo:
|
